The City Auditor’s Office has released an extensive report assessing Denton’s community housing initiatives, emphasizing the progress made in addressing housing affordability while identifying challenges related to funding sustainability, outreach, and program management. The report provides a comprehensive evaluation of the Affordable Housing Strategic Toolkit and related housing assistance programs, offering actionable recommendations to enhance their impact.
Affordable Housing Strategic Toolkit: A Key Initiative
The City of Denton adopted its Affordable Housing Strategic Toolkit in February 2022 to address growing challenges in housing affordability. The toolkit focuses on five strategies:
- Infill Development
- Zoning Relief
- Capacity Building and Resource Expansion
- Preservation of Affordability
- Improving Access to Housing Information
Initial steps have been taken, such as awarding $200,000 in one-time American Rescue Plan Capacity Building Grants to local housing nonprofits and developing tools to identify vacant sites for potential housing projects. Additionally, amendments to the Denton Development Code now allow small home communities, and public dashboards track the status of toolkit implementation.
While these efforts are promising, the audit cautions that the reliance on voter-approved bond funding for 2025-2027 is not a sustainable solution. The City must secure alternative funding sources to fully implement the toolkit over its planned 10-year timeline.
Housing Assistance Programs: Progress and Gaps
The City administers several programs aimed at increasing housing stability for low-income residents:
- Minor Repair Program: Provides essential repairs and modifications to homeowners. In 2023, this program exceeded goals, assisting 43 households.
- Rental Repair Program: Targets property owners to rehabilitate rental units, making them affordable for low-income tenants. Few applications were received in 2023 due to restrictive eligibility requirements, which have since been adjusted.
- Homebuyer Assistance Program: Supports first-time buyers with down payments and closing costs. This program also saw limited participation in 2023, hindered by rising property prices.
The audit revealed that these programs align with federal HUD guidelines, but public awareness remains a significant barrier. Enhanced outreach efforts, informed by demographic data, are recommended to increase participation.
Efficiency and Management Enhancements
The City’s transition to a centralized electronic application system remains incomplete, with some program documentation still managed manually. Fully adopting the system would streamline operations, reduce inconsistencies, and improve compliance with HUD grant requirements. The audit also highlighted the need for:
- Updated procedures for monitoring program outcomes.
- Clear guidelines for reviewing applications and grant drawdown requests.
- Targeted engagement to reach underrepresented communities, such as Asian households, who appear to face greater housing challenges but are less likely to apply for assistance.
Recommendations from the Audit
To address these challenges, the report outlined seven key recommendations:
- Secure sustainable funding for the Affordable Housing Strategic Toolkit.
- Establish metrics to measure toolkit outcomes, including housing unit production and return on investment.
- Improve marketing by gathering data on how applicants learn about housing programs.
- Develop detailed procedures for the Rental Repair and Homebuyer Assistance Programs.
- Ensure all application and project documentation is stored centrally.
- Enhance monitoring of grant drawdown requests and supporting documentation.
City officials have agreed to implement these recommendations, with progress timelines spanning 2024-2025.
Audit Conclusion
The audit praised the City’s compliance with HUD guidelines and its commitment to affordable housing through innovative initiatives like the Affordable Housing Strategic Toolkit. However, it emphasized that funding sustainability, program outreach, and operational efficiency must remain top priorities to achieve long-term housing equity in Denton.
For more details, the Audit of Community Housing Initiatives (PDF) report is available for public review.